AI coding tools range from editor assistants to app-building agents. Some help inside an existing repository; others create a new project from a brief. Choose according to where the code will live, how it will be maintained and who needs to review it. An AI code assistant is most useful when its output can be inspected, executed and corrected within your normal development process.
For an established codebase, look for repository search, project instructions, readable diffs and access to the commands your team uses. Inline completion helps while you type; an agent can investigate a bug, change several files and run checks. Those are different levels of involvement, even when one product offers both.
For a new application, the development environment matters as much as the code generator. Decide who will manage authentication, databases, hosting and future changes. A founder exploring a prototype may value an integrated browser workspace. A developer maintaining a production service may prefer an assistant inside an existing editor or terminal, with the repository and deployment process already established.
These published tools illustrate different starting points. Follow their documentation for supported environments and account requirements rather than assuming every feature works in every editor.
| Tool | Documented workflow | Useful distinction |
|---|---|---|
| GitHub Copilot | Completion and chat, plus IDE agents that edit files and run commands. | Keep a supported editor; compare IDE features with the separate cloud-agent workflow. |
| Cursor | Agent searches the project, changes files and uses the terminal within its editor. | Review generated diffs and accept or reject changes as part of the editing workflow. |
| Claude Code | Repository work through a terminal agent, with additional IDE, desktop and web surfaces. | Fits command-line workflows; account and provider options vary by surface. |
| Devin Desktop, formerly Windsurf | Manage local and cloud coding agents alongside a full IDE and diff review. | The current product continues the Windsurf editor foundation under its new name. |
| Replit | Agent sets up and builds a project in an online workspace, with planning and publishing. | Combines app creation and infrastructure; review ongoing cloud usage as well as AI usage. |
GitHub’s agent documentation distinguishes planning, IDE work and cloud delegation. Cursor’s Agent guide describes its search, editing and terminal tools. Devin’s official page confirms the Windsurf transition and its agent-management workspace.
Suppose a project’s CSV import accepts an empty customer email and fails later during processing. Give the assistant the import handler, validation conventions, a small fictional CSV and the expected error message. Ask it to explain the current path before proposing a patch. Specify that unrelated formatting, dependencies and database changes are outside the task.
Review the proposed diff, dependency choices and explanations, then run the existing checks. Exercise valid input, a blank email and a malformed row. Confirm that the error reaches the user and that valid rows still import. For a new app, verify the complete flow from user input through stored data. Save the accepted patch in version control so another developer can understand and maintain it.
Replit’s Plan mode provides a planning stage before implementation, while its checkpoints provide a way back during iteration. In any environment, a rollback helps recover work; it does not prove the change was correct.
GitHub and Cursor offer limited free access and paid plans, with different usage allowances and team controls. Compare the current Copilot plans and Cursor pricing against the features you need. Claude Code’s setup guide explains subscription, Console and supported provider routes. Replit documents AI and cloud billing; a working preview is only one part of operating an application.
Keep secrets out of example prompts and check workspace permissions. Review what an agent may read, change or execute, and which connected services it can reach. Team access rules and data-handling terms deserve attention before using proprietary repositories.
Generated code needs the same review as other code. Check access control, failure handling and whether the solution fits the project’s conventions. An appealing preview or a passing build alone does not establish that the application behaves correctly. Inspect changed dependencies, migration behavior and any external requests introduced by the patch.
Compare one representative task in the editors you could maintain long term. Judge context handling, diff review and compatibility with your workflow, alongside usage costs.
App-building agents can create substantial projects. You still need to verify permissions, data persistence and failure paths before relying on the result.
It may suit occasional assistance. Check model access, request allowances and the specific agent features needed for your task before choosing a plan.